Mainstays 2-in-1 Waffle & Sandwich Maker Review | Pros, Cons & Buying Guide

If you love quick breakfasts or evening snacks, but don’t want multiple appliances cluttering your kitchen counter top, a 2-in-1 waffle and sandwich maker can feel like a lifesaver. Recently I tried one, and while it impressed me in many ways, it also came with a few trade-offs you should know before buying. Here’s my detailed review based on my experience using it for over a month. 

Product Overview

• What it is: Mainstays 2-in-1 waffle and sandwich maker from Walmart. It's priced at 29.98 CAD (plus taxes) and comes with interchangeable plates for waffles and sandwiches.
• Who it’s for: Small families, students, busy parents, or anyone who enjoys versatile cooking without without crowding their counters with multiple gadgets.
• First impression: Lightweight, easy to set up, and it heats up faster than I expected.

Pros ✅

• Quick cooking: It makes two waffles or two sandwiches at a time, so breakfast or snacks are ready in a flash.
• Ease of use: Plug, preheat, and cook — no complicated settings.
• Compact design: Saves counter space and is easy to store.
• Dual purpose: One appliance, so many options making it perfect for small kitchens.

Cons ❌

• Not ideal for stuffed sandwiches: If you love your sandwiches thick and loaded, this one might feel a bit restrictive. It doesn't have enough room and trying to close the lid leaves us with compressed sandwiches. It’s great for simple sandwiches, but anything overloaded will get a little smooshed. 
• Non-stick coating: Works well considering the ease of using and cleaning, but if you're avoiding teflon-like surfaces, this might not be for you.
• Utensil restrictions: Must use only silicone, plastic, or wooden tools to avoid scratching.
• No sound indication: I wish it had an audible alert when preheating or cooking is done. I often found myself checking it multiple times, waiting—if it had an audible cue, I could have been multitasking instead.
• No on/off switch: It would be so much more convenient if there were a simple power button. Right now, every time you want to pause or stop cooking, you have to unplug and plug it back in—definitely a small hassle during busy mornings.

Like what you read? Follow me on YouTube for fresh videos and updates on every new post!

Tips to Get the Best Results:

• Lightly butter or oil the plates to extend the life of non-stick plates.
• Stick to medium fillings sandwiches - don't overstuff 
• Preheat fully before adding batter for crisp waffles.
• Always let the plates cool down well before cleaning for longer durability. 

Who Should Buy It?

• Great for small households, students, or anyone who loves quick, fuss-free cooking 
• It's compact and lightweight design makes it suitable to carry while traveling
• If you’re into gourmet stuffed sandwiches or extra-crispy restaurant-style waffles, you may prefer a higher-end, specialized appliance. 

Alternative Uses:

• Sandwich plate: Make hash browns, quesadillas, veggie cheese pockets and many more.
• Waffle plate: Thinking of many possibilities - waffle omelets, potato waffles, and desi style veggie waffle, ragi waffles etc.

 I will be sharing some simple and wonderful recipes soon on my Youtube channel - stay tuned!!

My Take

Mainstays 2-in-1 waffle and sandwich maker is worth considering if you want convenience and versatility in one gadget. It won’t replace a professional waffle iron or panini press, but for everyday quick meals, it gets the job done efficiently.

Watch my detailed demo and review video here.